|
Cardio vs. Weight Training: Which type of overtraining is worse? Why?
Speaking from personal
experience, I have been a competitive endurance athlete from over 10 years
of my life and since retiring four years ago I have been a serious weight
lifter who competes in competitive fitness modeling which is similar to
bodybuilding but without the posing or speedo's!
Hands down, overtraining in
the weight room has far more consequences than
overtraining
through cardio. Here are a few reasons why
· Muscles grow based
on progressive overload. If your muscles are not FULLY recovered
than it is impossible to lift more in the gym the next workout
therefore impossible to grow NEW muscle.
· Greater chance of
central nervous system fatigue, hormonal fatigue and immune system
fatigue which all have a list of endless problems.
· Overtraining in the
gym can in fact result in loss of muscle mass and decreased bone
density therefore digging yourself in a deeper hole and making it
even more difficult to build muscle.
· Overtraining in the
gym can lead a young trainee to believe that he needs to buy more
supplements which distracts him from discovering the route cause of
his lack of progress.
· Overtraining in the
gym can lead a young trainee to believe he should resort to steroids
because of his lack of progress when really it is simply a lack of
recovery.
· And most
importantly, overtraining in the gym will not allow the trainee to
achieve the desired training effect. In this case there will be no
forward progress or improvement in work capacity, but rather a
reduction.
In my experience, I believe
the only athletes that risk overtraining with cardio are pure endurance
athletes such as swimmers, bikers, runners and triathletes. These athletes
are training up to a few hours per day and bodybuilders do not come anywhere
close to the volume that endurance athletes train.
How does one know if
they’ve over-trained? What are some of the symptoms?
This is quite simple. Your
performance does not exceed or 'out do' your previous workout. If in your
last workout you bench pressed 10 reps for 185 lbs but could only do 8 reps
your next workout – you have NOT experienced the 'training effect' and
therefore have not FULLY recovered from your last workout. You have errored
somewhere in your training decisions.
Generally overtraining can be
determined in the simplest ways such as verbal feedback between the coach
and athlete or athlete and himself. An example would be a coach asking a
athlete at the beginning of a workout, “How do you feel today?” If the
response is, “My legs feel heavy and stiff' or “I don't feel good,” this
indicates that the athlete has not adapted to the previous days training
load. Even looking into someone's eyes can provided effective feedback.
Overtraining symptoms can be divided into two main categories
Physiological Performance
· Decreased
performance
· Inability to meet
previous workout standards
· Delayed recovery
· Reduced toleration
to load
· Decreased maximum
work capacity
· Loss of coordination
· Slower movement
patterns
· Technique breaking
down at quicker rate
· Rapid heart increase
· Changes in blood
pressure
· Changes in heart
rate at rest, exercise and recovery
· Increased
respiration
· Increased oxygen
consumption at sub max work loads
· Increased lactic
acid
· Decreased evening
post workout weight
· Chronic fatigue
Psychological
Performance
· Feeling of
depression
· General apathy
· Decreased
self-esteem
· Emotional
instability
· Difficulty
concentrating
· Sensitive to
environmental and emotional stress
· Fear of competition
· Change in
personality
· Loss of
concentration
· Inability to deal
with lots of information at once
· Gives up when going
gets tough
What are some ways to prevent overtraining through diet and
training?
I believe that the lack of
progress to training is more often the cause of overtraining than any other
factor. As we have discussed, overtraining begins when a trainee is exposed
to a subsequent training session prior to recovering from the previous. If
this occurs over a number of training sessions, you start to see the more
obvious signs of overtraining as listed above.
Personally, I think there is
too much information on the symptoms instead rather than the prevention of
them. You often read the words 'overtraining syndrome' and 'planned
overtraining'. This is unnecessary if are in control of the training process
and recovery process. If you start training to pre-set levels and recovery
in pre-planned ways than you can easily side-step overtraining and do not
need to know anything about signs and symptoms and syndromes!
Take control of your
training decisions!
The biggest challenge with
weight training is to make tough training decisions. Each workout program
and each workout session you must decide how much
· how much to lift and
· how hard to go.
You must apply your own
personal knowledge of your recovery ability and the recovery methods you are
using to so that when you return to the gym you will be able to 'out do'
your previous workout.
Here is the problem. Often
times a trainee returns to the gym to discover they have not fully recovered
and has a training decision to make – walk out and go home or reduce the
volume and intensity of the workout.
The smart decision would be to
accept the error in judgment, assess where you went wrong to prevent for the
future and go home! Remember, you have this flexibility so don't be afraid
to make this brave training decision. Your goal is to be getting stronger
and stronger from week to week. Not to 'tough it out' with mediocre workouts
that can lead to frustration and risk of injury. Don't ignore it or pretend
that it is not happening. The beauty of strength training is that it is so
measurable!
If you don't want your trip to
the gym to do in complete vain than finish up with a flexibility session and
try to pick of the digits of the cute receptionist at the front desk!
Preventing overtraining
with nutrition
Nutrition plays the
critical role of replacing energy in the body, and controlling hormone
release. Here are some simple recommendations:
· Never miss
breakfast! This is the meal that 'breaks the fast'. Extending this
fast can be very catabolic and cause in loss of muscle tissue.
· Avoid hunger pains
at all costs. This is a sure-fire way that your body is stealing
from your precious muscle to give to more vital organs. This is very
catabolic.
· Don't train hungry
unless your goal is to lose weight and muscle mass. Catabolism will
be even greater than normal.
· Even if you are not
hungry, pretend that you are hungry and eat something within sixty
to ninety minutes prior to working out.
· Never miss your post
workout shake. The sooner you get this in your body the better.
Focus on a 2:1 ratio of simple carbs and protein in liquid form plus
branch chain amino acids.
· Always have the
biggest meal of the day one hour after you workout.
· Consider supplements
such as creatine and antioxidants to help accelerate cellular
hydration and energy replacement; and combat the free radical damage
in the body.
· Replenishing your
glycogen stores will inhibit the cortisol hormone which can result
in breaking down muscle.
· Eat in hormonal
balance the remainder of the day to ensure cortisol levels stay
suppressed.
----------------------------------
About the Author:
Vince DelMonte is the author
of No Nonsense Muscle Building: Skinny Guy Secrets To Insane Muscle Gain
found at
www.VinceDelMonteFitness.com
He specializes in teaching
skinny guys
how to build muscle and gain
weight quickly without drugs, supplements and training less
than before.
Return to
Overtraining
© COPYRIGHT 2008 ALL RIGHTS
RESERVED HEALTHYBIZ2000.COM |